Bali bombers lose appeal against firing squad
Indonesia's top court on Tuesday rejected a request by three death-row Bali bombers to have their executions carried out by a different method than firing squad, saying that the alternatives also were painful.
"The pain suffered by the death-convicted is a legal consequence linked to the execution," Chief Judge Muhammad Mahfud said.
Lawyers for the three death-row Bali bombers had asked the country's Constitutional Court to consider the legality of death by firing squad, arguing it was "unconstitutional" because the men might not die immediately and calling the method a form of "torture."
The lawyers said the condemned militants wanted the death sentences to be conducted by traditional Islamic-style decapitation instead.
But the court on Tuesday rejected the argument, saying all execution methods carried some risk that death would not be immediate.
"There is no way to guarantee there will be no pain. All have a risk of inaccuracy, and will create suffering, but it's not torture," Mahfud said, adding that "the plaintiffs' request is not based on law, and must be rejected."
The three - Imam Samudra, Amrozi and his brother Ali Ghufron alias Mukhlas - received death sentences over their roles in the 2002 Bali bombings, which killed 202 people, mostly foreign visitors. The three have never shown remorse for the bombings of the two nightspots.
The Indonesian Attorney General's office is expected to announce details of the executions on Friday. Prosecutors have said the three should be executed by the end of the year.
Imam Samudra, Mukhlas and Amrozi, known also as the "smiling assassin," were members of Jemaah Islamiyah, the al-Qaeda-linked regional terrorist network responsible for several bombings across Indonesia.
These include simultaneous church bombings on Christmas Eve 2000, bombings on Bali in 2002 and 2005, the bombing of a JW Marriott hotel in Jakarta in 2004 and an attack on the Australian Embassy in 2005.
Indonesian authorities have arrested and jailed hundreds of militants in the past few years, seriously damaging the group, terrorism experts say.
- Login or register to post comments
Print
Email to friend
Related Articles
- Bali bombers lose appeal against firing squad
- Indonesia to execute death-row Bali bombers early November
- Death-row Bali bombers plan to file another appeal
- Ramadan delays three Bali bombers' executions
- Death row Bali bombers file another appeal
- Indonesian authorities visit Bali bombers' families
- Indonesian authorities visit Bali bombers' families
- Indonesia executes three Bali bombers
There has been an up side to the abysmal state of American economy, as more multi-generation families are choosing to live together, driven partly...
Apparently, the healthcare debate has forced into the Twilight Zone, with President Obama saying passing the bill means 3,000% decrease for...
University of Michigan researchers have found a chemical in bananas they believe can prove helpful in protecting women from HIV infection.
...
Prosecutors say a former Fall River dentist who has had his license to practice suspended in three states repeatedly billed for work using the...
In a special edition of the Journal of the American Medical Association, commentators say the US health system is under strain from the rising...
In its letter released Tuesday, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) informs Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Ltd. to have sold nitroglycerin tablets...
In an exciting win for gene testing and personalized medicine, doctors say it is possible to get a tricky dose right and keep patients out of...
According to US researchers, while younger people with colon cancer are more likely to receive chemotherapy after surgery than older patients, it...
Adopting a controversial plan the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene proposed 14 months ago, the New York City Board of Health will rate...
Law enforcement officials and marijuana advocates for Washington State have been called upon to change how pot is regulated and how those who grow...
Kathleen Sebelius, Secretary of Health and Human Services said Tuesday immediate benefits will be visible to consumers via increased insurer...
As the lawmakers clashed fiercely Tuesday, political manoeuvring in the Capitol saw Democrats struggling to defend procedural shortcuts in order...












